T(r)oy's Marbles
8. the alternate account
This is the 8th and final part of a multi-part essay dealing with issues related to "The Da Vinci Code" and the Gnostic Gospels.
To start the series at the beginning, click here. From there, you'll find links at the end of each part, directing you to the next post in the chain.
Today we will conclude our discussion/exploration rather briefly. I promise.
Conclusion, at last!
Thanks for bearing with the length of this essay. I wanted, however, to give a comprehensive picture as to the real alternate account that Dan Brown presents in his book The Da Vinci Code.
You’ll recall that we said it may prove useful to adopt a “presuppositional” approach to the question. The way this looks in this instance is by taking a serious look at the alternative proposed (as a way of evaluating the merits of the alternative in its own right, on its own terms).
You recall that we said we could evaluate, for example, the merits of atheism by granting the atheist their presupposition that God does not exist and then by proceeding to think through all the stuff that comes with that assertion (whether we like it or not). It’s the “if this…then that” line of reasoning.
So, what we have attempted to do in this instance was to take Dan Brown at his word (viz., that the dissenting voices in the early centuries A.D. actually had something valid to say, something truthful to contribute).
Now, let it be noted: we can choose to believe that, well…maybe the Gnostics had a point. Maybe they were right about Jesus.
But, if you choose to believe that, keep in mind you’d better start boning up on your mathematics and mythology, because most of what the Gnostic Jesus told them involved numbers and fairy tales. (Not just some of what he told them, mind you: most of).
Or, you can choose to believe the only other version that was told: the version that Jesus came and said simpler (yet still rich, deep) things like:
“Love your enemies.”
“Bless those who curse you.”
“Do not judge.”
“I am gentle and humble.”
“I am the good shepherd.”
“I am the bread of life.”
“I and the Father are one.”
“Do not worry.”
“Father, forgive them.”
and
“Follow me.”
Hm. I wonder what really happened?
teachings | Comments (1) | March 16, 2007
Comments
So what are you going to rant about next baby? :)
Posted by: The Wife at March 17, 2007 12:06 PM